Skip to content

Satellite & Orbital Infrastructure

Luckey says U.S. blocks Ukraine from using Starshield network

Luckey said Starshield is the Pentagon's military satellite network and that SpaceX helps run it, with military terminals operating in Ukraine in October.

https://orbital-wire.com/satellite-infrastructure/luckey-us-blocks-ukraine-starshield-network/

Key facts

  • SpaceX helps run Starshield, Luckey said at The New York Times' DealBook Summit in New York.
  • Starshield service in Ukraine was restored later in October after the Oct. 14 link drops.
  • Who ordered the Oct. 14 cap is disputed: Reuters cited U.S. and Western officials saying the order came from inside the White House, while the Wall Street Journal cited officials saying Elon Musk ordered it.
  • SpaceX and Elon Musk have denied ordering the cap on Starshield.

At The New York Times’ DealBook Summit in New York on Wednesday, Palmer Luckey said the U.S. government would block Ukraine from Starshield, citing concern that Russia would destroy the network.

Luckey described Starshield as the Pentagon’s military satellite network, said military Starshield terminals were operating in Ukraine in October, and said SpaceX helps run Starshield. On Oct. 14, Musk posted on X that Starshield belongs to and is run by the U.S. government, with limits set by the U.S. military and ultimately POTUS. Andrew Cavalier, principal analyst at ABI Research, wrote on Oct. 28 that ownership and control of Starshield rest with the U.S. government, along with any decision on limits.

Luckey argued that Washington would not risk its own constellation, so Musk should not have to risk Starlink. He defended Musk during the same DealBook session.

Military Starshield terminals in Ukraine cut out on Oct. 14 above roughly 100 mph, Ukrainian units reported, while interceptor drones lost connections during flight. Starshield service in Ukraine was restored later in October after the Oct. 14 link drops. Zelenskyy said on Nov. 12 that Starshield service had returned, and on Nov. 17 that it remained in place over occupied territory.

Who ordered the Oct. 14 cap is disputed. Reuters cited U.S. and Western officials saying the order came from inside the White House, while the Wall Street Journal cited officials saying Elon Musk ordered it. “A senior U.S. official told Reuters the president made no such request.” SpaceX and Elon Musk have denied ordering the cap on Starshield.

Zelenskyy called the October Starshield cap a planned operation on Oct. 17. Germany pays for Starshield under a contract running through April 2027, and Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul told broadcaster ntv on Oct. 16 that the restrictions must be lifted.

The Space Force’s Commercial Satellite Communications Office set up the Warrior Plans program in September 2025 to buy proliferated LEO service for the Joint Force. June contract notices split the first two Warrior Plans task orders, awarding one to SpaceX for Starshield and the other to OneWeb Technologies for OneWeb services. Eutelsat Network Solutions disclosed a Warrior Plans award on Nov. 17 valued at more than $60 million across two years, covering OneWeb airtime, deployable terminals and alternative positioning, navigation and timing.

BISI counts about 650 OneWeb satellites versus more than 10,000 Starlink spacecraft, while Cavalier says OneWeb does not match Starlink’s terminal and capacity scale. BISI puts the value of France’s armed forces contract for priority military access to OneWeb at up to €1 billion. Andrew Cavalier says Starlink is still dominant but has lost its uncontested default status, and that procurement now treats operator jurisdiction and unilateral restriction authority as explicit scoring criteria.

Months before October, the military customer with the most Starshield access chose to keep a second LEO network under contract, selecting one already in orbit. SatNews says the award’s significance lies in this pre-October choice rather than its size. Nothing in the Nov. 17 Warrior Plans award announcement explains how it connects to the June contract notices. The sum of the Nov. 17 Warrior Plans award is modest by Pentagon standards.

According to SatNews, the October cap created a concrete new reason for governments to seek a second low Earth orbit network. NATO began implementing STARLIFT on Nov. 17; it is a brokerage through which militaries can reserve commercial rocket slots at spaceports in member countries and South Korea. STARLIFT funding was pledged on Oct. 29 by Belgium, Canada, Finland, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and Seoul.

IRIS2, Europe’s own constellation, has first launches scheduled for 2029, leaving it years away from operation compared with OneWeb, which is already in service. SatNews reported on Oct. 29 that Ukraine has placed a test satellite in orbit for a sovereign network. None of the alternative networks, including Taiwan’s talks, IRIS2 and Ukraine’s test satellite, carries traffic yet.

At Space Symposium in April, Taiwan Space Agency Director General Wu Jong-shinn proposed a shared constellation for like-minded countries. Aviation Week reported on Nov. 16 that the Taiwan Space Agency holds preliminary talks with three to four partners concerning more than 300 communications satellites in a network developed by private companies, citing the Ukraine throttling. The Taiwan Space Agency wants involvement from U.S. companies and cited CesiumAstro’s role in its Beyond 5G demonstrator. There is no published budget or schedule for Taiwan’s proposed shared constellation.

Before Nov. 15, Amazon Leo had put 396 satellites into orbit, though a United Launch Alliance Vulcan failure destroyed 40 more, and the constellation still requires more than 3,300. Amazon booked 38 launches on Vulcan, 24 on Blue Origin’s New Glenn, 24 on Ariane 6 and 13 on Falcon 9, according to Spaceflight Now. An FAA-overseen investigation covers Vulcan, New Glenn has not flown since a May pad explosion, and Ariane 6 has completed four flights this year versus a target of seven to eight. Ariane 6’s next flight, carrying 36 Amazon Leo satellites, is scheduled for no earlier than Nov. 23, according to ESA, and Falcon 9 commercial capacity is winding down.

Bar chart, Amazon Leo launch bookings by rocket. Vulcan: 38; New Glenn: 24; Ariane 6: 24; Falcon 9: 13.

Amazon Leo is also a U.S. company under the same government oversight, meaning a buyer concerned about one government’s control of its links would still rely on Washington. Clayton Swope, deputy director of the Aerospace Security Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, told Breaking Defense the launch bottleneck is real and will keep getting worse after the Vulcan failure. Operators with spare capacity and multi-network terminals can sell into the hedge market now.

Luckey said he likes Musk personally, which is why he advised taking Musk’s view with a pound of salt.

Share

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *