Skip to content

Astronomy & Astrophysics Discoveries

University of Michigan team finds no evidence of hidden black hole in galaxy UHZ1

Phys.org reports the reanalysis challenges the earlier claim that UHZ1 hosted an unusually massive, dust-obscured direct-collapse black hole.

https://orbital-wire.com/astronomy-astrophysics/evidence-hidden-black-hole-galaxy-uhz1/

Key facts

  • A research team led by Fan Zou at the University of Michigan reexamined galaxy UHZ1 by combining archival X-ray measurements with fresh infrared observations and detected no evidence of hidden black hole activity.
  • JWST's deep NIRCam imaging first revealed UHZ1, and later estimates placed the galaxy at a cosmic time around 480 million years after the Big Bang, corresponding to redshift 10.
  • Earlier researchers using the Chandra X-ray telescope detected a small excess of high-energy X-rays from UHZ1 and interpreted the signal as gas feeding a black hole, identifying the galaxy as an active galactic nucleus.
  • For the reanalysis, the team reprocessed all old Chandra data and added 0.95 million seconds of fresh Chandra observations, while also examining new mid-infrared JWST data that extend the wavelength range.

Fan Zou at the University of Michigan led a research team that reexamined galaxy UHZ1 using archival X-ray measurements and fresh infrared observations and found no evidence that a black hole was active in the galaxy, in work The Astrophysical Journal published on Oct. 14, 2026.

The paper appears as Revisiting the Claim for a Direct-collapse Black Hole in UHZ1 at z = 10.05 by Fan Zou et al. in The Astrophysical Journal (2026), DOI 10.3847/1538-4357/aea0cc. This citation points to the peer-reviewed study challenging the earlier UHZ1 black-hole headline.

Phys.org reports that UHZ1 first appeared in JWST‘s deep NIRCam imaging, and that later estimates dated the galaxy to about 480 million years after the Big Bang at redshift 10.

Earlier researchers placed the black hole at roughly 10 million to 100 million solar masses, a mass about equal to all the galaxy’s stars, which supported the heavy-seed picture. Three years ago, UHZ1 made headlines for an unusually massive, heavily dust-obscured black hole formed by direct collapse.

The Chandra X-ray telescope had previously picked up a small excess of high-energy X-rays from UHZ1, which earlier researchers took as gas feeding a black hole and labeled the galaxy an active galactic nucleus. Hints in the data also pointed to a black hole hidden inside thick gas.

That original direct-collapse reading rested heavily on assumptions, while the earlier JWST spectrum showed no black-hole signature, and the key diagnostic features were outside the instrument’s wavelength range so the team could not check them then. Heavy dust blocking the black hole’s emission was the original team’s explanation. For the reanalysis, the team went back over all old Chandra data and added fresh Chandra observations totaling 0.95 million seconds, and it examined new mid-infrared JWST data extending the wavelength range.

The reanalysis produced a weaker X-ray detection, and the result changed based on how the X-ray image lined up with the JWST image. A real, steady X-ray source should have become brighter with the added 0.95 million seconds of fresh Chandra observations, but the new data contributed almost nothing.

The team ran simulations of many plausible X-ray/JWST image alignments to test how often such a strong signal could arise. Only 0.1% matched the strength of the original UHZ1 claim, and most simulated placements failed to reproduce the original strong signal.

JWST’s MIRI instrument detected no mid-infrared glow of the type expected when a powerful black hole hidden in dust heats nearby dust. That non-detection caps a hidden black hole’s possible brightness without proving no black hole exists.

Using two hidden-black-hole templates scaled to the detection limit, the team calculated that the maximum plausible brightness fell 10 to 1,000 times short of what the original X-ray claim needed. That rules out an outsize black hole with the power originally proposed.

The team tested two ways a black hole could stay hidden – a dust-free gas cloud and distant cold dust – and neither matched the observations. A dust-free hidden black hole fails because its visible and ultraviolet light would appear in JWST data, but it does not. Distant cold dust is ruled out because ALMA found very little dust in the galaxy and the galaxy’s light is barely dimmed.

The galaxy is instead low-mass, metal-poor and star-forming, according to the new study, with about 100 million solar masses in stars. The researchers say ordinary star formation explains the galaxy’s emission lines, so no black hole is needed to account for them.

The team’s principal conclusion is that there is no compelling evidence for an active galactic nucleus, and it says the X-ray signal now looks far less significant than first claimed. Zou’s team says that because the original claim was extraordinary, it requires stronger proof, and the claim that a luminous buried black hole exists does not meet that bar.

The result takes away the compelling case for an active galactic nucleus in UHZ1, revising the earlier headlines about the galaxy’s outsize black hole. Under the heavy-seed picture, such a hole formed directly from collapsing gas instead of growing slowly from a single star’s remnant.

Share

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *