Skip to content

Planetary Science & Skywatching

Study concludes Earth accreted increasingly oxidized material, limiting Theia’s size

The models applied an N-body accretion framework across Classical, Annulus and Grand Tack scenarios to test Proto-Earth and Theia properties.

https://orbital-wire.com/planetary-science-skywatching/earth-accretion-oxidized-material-limiting-theia-size/

Key facts

  • The researchers conclude that Earth incorporated progressively more oxidized building blocks over time as the planet grew.
  • The models indicate that reproducing Earth's composition requires both a radial increase in oxidation across the inner disk and a trend toward more oxidized material during accretion.
  • A pronounced oxidation gradient in the starting disk solids best explains Earth's mantle chemistry, consistent with Rubie et al. (2015b).
  • Late accretion is oxidizing in every proposed formation scenario, which means Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both have mantles more oxidized than present-day Earth.

Gabriel Nathan submitted a study to arXiv on Nov. 10, 2026, concluding that Earth incorporated progressively more oxidized building blocks over time as the planet grew. The same simulations find Theia can have a mantle more oxidized than present-day Earth only if the impactor is small compared with Proto-Earth. The authors analyzed mantle chemistry to assess which formation scenarios could yield an Earth-like planet and to narrow down the possible nature of Proto-Earth and Theia.

The researchers turned to mantle chemistry because existing formation scenarios already reproduce key features of the inner Solar System. They needed a stricter test to distinguish among those scenarios.

They applied an N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation framework from Rubie et al. (2011, 2015b) across Classical, Annulus and Grand Tack formation scenarios. The group varied the initial conditions to see which combinations of impactor mass and mantle chemistry could reproduce Earth’s bulk composition. Successful simulations do not lock in a single mantle chemistry or impactor mass ratio for Proto-Earth and Theia, allowing many combinations to fit Earth’s composition.

N-body accretion simulates how many planetary embryos pull on one another gravitationally, collide and merge as they grow into larger bodies over time. Core-mantle differentiation models how metal separates from silicate inside each growing body, shaping the chemistry of the resulting planet.

The process determines how elements distribute between the metallic core and the silicate mantle during planetary formation. Together these tools let the researchers track how oxidation states evolved as planets assembled through collisions and core formation. By varying the initial redox state of solids in a synthetic disk, the researchers sought a match between the simulated planet’s mantle and the bulk silicate Earth, the combined composition of the planet’s mantle and crust.

Redox state describes the oxidation level of the materials used in the starting disk. The models indicate that reproducing Earth’s composition requires both a radial increase in oxidation across the inner disk and a trend toward more oxidized material during accretion. A radial increase means solids farther from the Sun were more oxidized than those closer to it.

The inner disk is the region close to the Sun where the terrestrial planets formed. A pronounced oxidation gradient in the starting disk solids best explains Earth’s mantle chemistry, consistent with Rubie et al. (2015b). The result supports the idea that the initial solids of the disk were unevenly oxidized.

This gradient aligns with prior research by Rubie and colleagues. Late accretion refers to material added to a planet after most of its mass has assembled, typically after the main phase of planetary growth. Because oxidized material arrives late in every proposed formation scenario, the model rules out both Theia and Proto-Earth having mantles more oxidized than present-day Earth. The widespread late delivery of oxidized material affects both bodies in the simulations.

The mass ratio refers to the impactor’s mass compared with Proto-Earth’s mass. Many combinations of impactor size and chemistry can fit Earth’s composition. The work narrows the possible nature of Proto-Earth and Theia by using mantle chemistry as an added test for their properties.

Gabriel Nathan submitted version 1 to arXiv on Nov. 10, 2026 at 23:46:35 UTC. The upload measured 20,088 KB. The paper carries the arXiv subject classification Earth and Planetary Astrophysics (astro-ph.EP); its categories are Astrobiology and Astrogeology. The Icarus paper by Nathan, Nguyen, and Jacobson was available online on Oct. 24, 2026.

Share

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *