Skip to content

Launch & Mission Tracking

ULA says inadequate fuel supply may have caused Vulcan Leo 1 failure

United Launch Alliance's preliminary finding points away from the BE-4 engine, and Blue Origin plans a New Glenn return to flight as soon as January.

https://orbital-wire.com/launch-mission-tracking/ula-vulcan-leo-1-failure-fuel-supply/

This is a new development in a story we reported earlier: Vulcan rocket failure destroyed 40 Amazon Leo satellites during Sunday launch.

Key facts

  • ULA said preliminary flight-data review indicates an inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle, not engine performance, caused low booster thrust during the Vulcan Leo 1 failure; final cause remains undetermined.
  • The preliminary finding points away from the BE-4 engine as the failure culprit, supporting Blue Origin's planned New Glenn return to flight as soon as January after a May ground-test explosion.
  • Amazon lost its largest Leo satellite batch to date; success would have raised its launched total to 436 satellites toward a first-generation constellation of more than 3,200.
  • NASA is considering a stretched Centaur 5 as an SLS Artemis 4 upper-stage option, and ULA's statements leave the Centaur 5 flight record intact because it has flown only on Vulcan.

United Launch Alliance said on Nov. 18 that a preliminary flight-data review indicates “inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines,” not engine performance, caused low booster thrust during the Vulcan Leo 1 failure. The company released the finding after completing an initial integrated review of flight information from the Nov. 15 anomaly. ULA said the Centaur upper stage and its RL10 engines started normally but could not recover from the first-stage shortfall. The final cause remains undetermined.

The Vulcan Leo 1 rocket failed about 10 minutes after it lifted off on Nov. 15, 2026, marking ULA’s first total failure in 20 years and the vehicle’s fifth flight. The rocket lifted off from Space Launch Complex 41 at the Cape Canaveral Space Force Station at 12:40 p.m. EST (1740 UTC), carrying 40 Amazon Leo satellites. ULA lost telemetry about 10 minutes into flight, ending any chance of completing the mission. Soon after liftoff the vehicle showed low first-stage performance, leading to stage separation while the rocket was flying too low and too slowly to reach orbit.

The preliminary finding points away from the BE-4 engine as the failure culprit, supporting Blue Origin’s planned New Glenn return to flight as soon as January after a May ground-test explosion. Blue Origin supported ULA’s flight-data review and agreed that inadequate vehicle fuel supply to the BE-4 engines, not engine performance, caused low booster thrust. The company called ULA a valued partner and expressed anticipation for Vulcan’s return to flight. The two BE-4 engines on Vulcan produce more than 1 million pounds of combined thrust and carried a Blue Origin oxygen-valve retrofit designed after the May 28 New Glenn ground-test explosion at Launch Complex 36.

Amazon lost its largest Leo satellite batch to date; success would have raised its launched total to 436 satellites toward a first-generation constellation of more than 3,200. Amazon had launched 396 Leo satellites across 14 successful missions beginning in April 2025, most recently on an Atlas 5 in July. The Federal Communications Commission allows deployment through July 30, 2029, for the full 3,232-satellite first generation. Amazon plans an Ariane 6 Leo mission with 36 satellites from French Guiana no earlier than Nov. 23.

The company purchased 38 Vulcan launches for its Leo satellite internet service, and the rocket will carry more than 1,500 first-generation Amazon satellites, the most of any rocket in the program.

ULA grounded Vulcan with no return-to-flight date, leaving the U.S. Space Force and Amazon waiting. The U.S. Space Force had hoped to use the rocket for national security payloads, and it has hesitated to use Vulcan until the booster anomalies are resolved. Both customers are waiting because ULA has set no return-to-flight date. Amazon’s remaining booked flights use Arianespace’s Ariane 6 and SpaceX’s Falcon 9 instead.

NASA is considering a stretched Centaur 5 as an SLS Artemis 4 upper-stage option, and ULA’s statements leave the Centaur 5 flight record intact because it has flown only on Vulcan. Under a NASA contract, ULA will supply Centaur V as the Space Launch System’s new upper stage for upcoming Moon missions. The Centaur V did not contribute to the Vulcan accident. NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman posted on X that Artemis, Moon Base, and the nation need ULA.

The FAA will oversee the ULA-led investigation, participate in every step, and approve ULA’s final report and any corrective actions. ULA did not identify which vehicle component failed to deliver enough fuel, and the company offered no reason. The next step is to identify what caused the fuel-component and pipeline issue that delivers liquid oxygen and methane to the BE-4 engines. ULA chief Mark Peller described the booster’s first-stage shortfall as significant, saying “we had a significant shortfall in booster first stage performance.”

He said the Centaur separated and ignited its RL10 engines, but the first stage left it in a low-energy state it could not overcome.

All six Northrop Grumman GEM 63XL solid rocket boosters performed nominally on Sunday, burning out roughly one minute and 35 seconds after liftoff following nozzle improvements. A nozzle malfunctioned during Vulcan’s second flight in October 2024, and another booster suffered apparent burn-through on the USSF-87 mission Feb. 12, causing a nine-month launch gap and a national-security launch suspension. Sunday’s flight aimed to demonstrate that fixes had worked. Three of Vulcan’s five flights experienced problems, but Sunday’s was the sole instance where the payload did not reach orbit; earlier solid-rocket-booster nozzle malfunctions occurred in October 2024 and February 2026.

ULA is a 50-50 Boeing-Lockheed Martin joint venture; Vulcan replaces Atlas V and Delta IV partly because Congress required ending U.S. reliance on Russian RD-180 engines for national security launches after Russia’s 2014 Crimea annexation. Atlas V has a 100 percent mission success record, Delta IV had a 100 percent success rate from 2006 through its final launch in 2024, and ULA was founded in 2006. Six Atlas V rockets remain, but they are under contract to Boeing for Starliner. The first stage uses two BE-4 methalox (methane and liquid oxygen) engines built by Blue Origin, which also flies them on New Glenn.

Vulcan can add two, four, or six side-mounted Northrop Grumman Solid Rocket Boosters when extra thrust is needed.

Blue Origin CEO Dave Limp replied Tuesday morning on X that ULA’s mission is to provide updates, that Blue Origin is supporting with BE-4 data and analysis, and that Team Blue continues readying the pad and New Glenn for return to flight. A Bloomberg report citing a memo from Limp said Blue Origin targets January for New Glenn’s return to flight, and an FCC filing from Blue Origin lists a Jan. 15 through April 15 window for a New Glenn launch plus preflight and postflight work. Both Vulcan and New Glenn are grounded, leaving Amazon waiting on its booked rides.

Share

Was this helpful?

Join the discussion

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting. First-time comments are held for moderation. By posting a comment you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which explain how your name, email address and comment are used.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *