Key facts
- The missing oxygen is likely in gaseous halos around the galaxies, known as the circumgalactic medium, and may have traveled farther into the intergalactic medium.
- Researchers used Hubble observations of individual stars to reconstruct star formation histories, then tallied oxygen present in gas, stars, and dust.
- Telford reports that about 15 percent of stellar oxygen in low-mass galaxies remains inside them today, mainly in gas with lesser amounts in stars and dust.
- Across the sample, galaxies kept between 4 percent and 25 percent of their stellar oxygen, averaging about 11 percent.
A team using the Hubble Space Telescope examined 37 nearby dwarf galaxies and found that much of the oxygen their stars should have produced is missing. The results appeared in The Astrophysical Journal as GLOW. II. A Census of Oxygen in Low-mass Galaxies.
The sample covers dwarf galaxies within roughly 19.5 million light-years from Earth, with stellar masses ranging from about 3 million to roughly 3 billion solar masses. NGC 4449, an irregular dwarf about 12 million light-years away in Canes Venatici, was among the galaxies examined. NASA released a Hubble photo of it on Nov. 2, 2026.
Researchers reconstructed star formation histories from Hubble observations of individual stars, then added up the oxygen found in gas, stars and dust. The team paired Hubble observations with Spitzer data and ground-based radio telescopes, including the Very Large Array and the Australian Telescope Compact Array.
Oxygen ranks as the third most abundant element in the cosmos, easy to detect and measure, and a trustworthy tracer of how chemical elements spread through a galaxy. Oxygen supports almost all life as we know it, and researchers have long used it to trace the chemical evolution of the cosmos. Because it marks other heavy elements created by stars, tracking where oxygen travels helps explain galaxy development and enrichment. Most oxygen comes from core-collapse supernovae, the explosive deaths of massive stars, with a small fraction from other supernovae involving remnants of low-mass stars.
According to Telford, no earlier study has measured both the oxygen retained by low-mass galaxies and the oxygen they lost across their lifetimes. “Most of the oxygen does come from core-collapse supernovae, which are the explosive deaths of massive stars, says Telford.”
Telford says roughly 15 percent of the oxygen produced by stars in low-mass galaxies stays inside them today, mostly in gas with smaller amounts in stars and dust. The studied galaxies retained from 4 percent to 25 percent of their oxygen, with an average near 11 percent. Nearly all that retained oxygen sits in gas rather than in stars or dust. For galaxies more than 3.3 million light-years from a massive neighbor, the retention rate stayed below 15 percent.
The Milky Way contains roughly one oxygen atom for every 2,000 hydrogen atoms. The dwarf galaxies in the sample show roughly one oxygen atom for every 10,000 to 20,000 hydrogen atoms.
Radiation from massive stars and their supernova explosions pushes oxygen-rich gas out of dwarf galaxies over time. Their weak gravity makes it difficult to keep gas that stellar winds and supernova explosions drive outward.
Much of the missing oxygen probably sits in gaseous halos around the galaxies, a region called the circumgalactic medium, and some of it may have moved even farther into the intergalactic medium (the space between galaxies). The study’s authors say most oxygen forced out by massive stars and supernovae ends up beyond the galaxies, though its exact location remains unconfirmed. Astronomers suspect massive stars and supernovae expelled the oxygen into surrounding space, but current data cannot show whether it floats in diffuse gas around the galaxies or escaped farther into intergalactic space.

Past ultraviolet studies of highly ionized oxygen explain roughly 1 to 7 percent of the oxygen produced, and revised estimates show halos might contain 5 to 35 percent.
Dwarf galaxies shed more oxygen than current galaxy formation models expect, which points to an incomplete understanding of how massive stars affect their host galaxies. Telford reached this conclusion from the GLOW results. Three cosmological simulations match the mass-metallicity relation yet forecast that dwarf galaxies keep more of their metals (elements heavier than helium) than the observations reveal.
A straightforward model fits the observations if outflows strip proportionally more mass from smaller galaxies, the outflowing gas carries twice the metal content of the interstellar medium, and gas accretion drops by roughly 40 percent. Current models may underestimate how effectively stellar winds and supernova explosions strip oxygen from dwarf galaxies.
Grace Telford, the paper’s second author, serves as an assistant professor in the University of Utah’s Department of Physics & Astronomy. Kristen Wingfield McQuinn leads the GLOW project as its principal investigator; she is an associate professor at Rutgers University and heads the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope Science Operations Center at the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore. “So, it’s really for practical reasons that we’ve chosen oxygen,” McQuinn said.
The GLOW effort receives funding from NASA and the National Science Foundation. It examines how gas and heavy elements flow among low-mass galaxies, their circumgalactic medium and the intergalactic medium. Telford says researchers need to combine new observations with archival data from ground-based and space telescopes when studying low-mass galaxies. Upcoming data from Hubble, the James Webb Space Telescope and the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope may help find the missing oxygen, and the team hopes to examine even smaller galaxies.
Telford notes that astronomers have already tracked oxygen and other heavy elements escaping from massive systems such as the Milky Way. If small galaxies regularly release large quantities of oxygen and other elements, they could help spread materials across the universe, and those materials might later become part of new stars and planets.
The spread in results might suggest that oxygen is flowing back into these galaxies or that they are pulling in gas enriched by neighboring galaxies. Outflows driven by supernovae represent a long-standing concept, and this research attaches firm figures to that idea.





Join the discussion