Key facts
- About 75 percent of the merger sample formed a peak at black holes of 10 solar masses.
- The data showed a distinct lack of black holes with masses from 12 to 16 solar masses, creating a gap in the mass distribution.
- Chatziioannou said the results connect gravitational-wave data with underlying astrophysics, and Legred said more research is needed to confirm the failed-supernova formation channel.
- In the standard model, a massive star's core collapses, shockwaves strike the outer layers and trigger a supernova explosion, and the collapsed core creates a black hole.
A Caltech-led team published a study of 257 black hole mergers from the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA network on Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2026, in Physical Review D, finding a gap between black holes of 12 and 16 solar masses in the merger population.
The researchers examined the mass distribution of 257 black hole mergers detected by the network over the past 10 years. About 75 percent of the sample formed a peak at black holes of 10 solar masses, which matched earlier expectations. The missing masses nearby were not predicted by those models, and the data showed a distinct lack of black holes from 12 to 16 solar masses, creating a gap in the distribution.
Ten-solar-mass black holes occupied a narrower range of spin rates than the sample. How black holes form influences spin rates, and the tighter distribution supports the idea that these objects are distinct from the wider black-hole population, indicating a shared origin such as the quiet implosion of massive stars.
In the standard model, a massive star’s core collapses, shockwaves strike the outer layers and trigger a supernova explosion, and the collapsed core creates a black hole. A failed supernova follows a different path in which the star vanishes without exploding, leaving a dark patch of sky. These events are difficult to observe directly because nothing visible marks the star’s disappearance.
Theories suggest some massive stars die without a supernova, directly collapsing inward to become neutron stars or black holes. Currently no hard evidence of failed supernovae exists, though scientists think a population of massive stars imploded rather than exploded, and their existence is well-supported theoretically.
The finding rested on gravitational-wave statistics and theoretical expectation rather than a direct observation. No one has made a direct observation of a failed supernova.
Isaac Legred (Ph.D. ’25), a postdoc at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign who performed the research while at Caltech, is the lead author. Jacob Golomb (Ph.D. ’25), now at Asari AI, is also an author and a former member of Chatziioannou’s lab. Katerina Chatziioannou, a professor of physics at Caltech and William H. Hurt Scholar, led the research. The paper, ‘Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 M ⊖ peak in the merging black hole mass distribution,’ appeared Nov. 10, 2026, in Physical Review D with DOI 10.1103/mnzq-w1b5 and arXiv ID 2604.01420.

LIGO operates detectors in Louisiana and Washington and made the first direct detection of gravitational waves in 2015 from colliding black holes. Virgo is in Italy and KAGRA, the Kamioka Gravitational-wave Detector, is in Japan. Both joined LIGO in a network that has since logged more than 300 black hole collisions, and the failed-supernova research follows that 2015 detection and the network’s expansion.
Earlier studies found that merging black holes often have masses around 10 solar masses, and theorists proposed this population may represent failed supernovae. The Caltech-led team set out to test whether that proposal was consistent with the gravitational-wave observations. If the channel is correct, either the heavier black hole in a merging pair or both black holes may have originated from stars that imploded rather than exploded.
The study found no direct evidence of failed supernovae, but concluded the gravitational-wave observations match what theorists predicted for such a population. Chatziioannou said the results connect gravitational-wave data with underlying astrophysics, and Legred said more research is needed to confirm the failed-supernova formation channel. The team described black holes as born in extreme environments and called better understanding of their formation exciting.
"We see 10-solar-mass black holes merging all the time," Legred says.
Isaac Legred, Phys.org
they may be a distinct subpopulation that failed to go supernova.
Katerina Chatziioannou, Space
Isaac Legred of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign asked why 14-solar-mass black holes are so rare, saying the gap points to a special cocktail of internal physics behind the 10-solar-mass abundance. Because these stars vanish without an explosion, failed supernovae are difficult to observe directly, and Legred said studying historical records of such stars is challenging for this reason.





Join the discussion