Key facts
- The samples also contained higher-than-expected aluminum, copper, lead, niobium and hafnium, with niobium and hafnium matching the ratio in an alloy used to make rocket engine nozzles.
- The FCC now enforces a five-year deorbit window, tighter than the historical industry practice of deorbiting within 25 years of mission termination.
- On September 8, 2024, scientists flew from Easter Island on a modified Dassault Falcon 900 jet and observed the first Cluster II satellite reenter over the southern Pacific Ocean, capturing about 20 seconds of data.
- ESA's Draco mission will launch in 2027 with a satellite designed to fall apart, carrying an indestructible capsule to protect data collected from the satellite surface during atmospheric breakup.
NOAA atmospheric chemist Daniel Murphy and colleagues detected lithium in stratospheric air samples collected over Fairbanks, Alaska, during early 2023 flights and traced the lithium to material left behind by satellites, Astronomy Magazine reported.
Daniel Murphy and colleagues flew through the stratosphere over Fairbanks in early 2023 hoping to measure baseline upper-atmosphere chemistry before proposed geoengineering aerosol injections could alter it, but they expected trace metals from meteoroids and found far more lithium in stratospheric particles than meteoroids typically contain.
The samples also contained higher-than-expected aluminum, copper, lead, niobium and hafnium, with niobium and hafnium matching the ratio in an alloy used to make rocket engine nozzles. These metals are scarcely found in meteoroids, and their presence pointed to spacecraft as the source.
In a 2023 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences report, Murphy and colleagues found that 10% of stratospheric aerosol particles carried metals from spacecraft. Researchers worry the metals could catalyze reactions that destroy ozone, alter cloud formation, or boost or buffer the greenhouse effect. Reentries have risen sharply in recent years as corporations and countries launch megaconstellations such as SpaceX’s Starlink, and all those satellites will inevitably deorbit.
SpaceX launched its first 60 Starlink satellites in May 2019. The constellation now exceeds 10,000 satellites, comprises roughly two-thirds of active satellites, and may grow to as many as 42,000. The Federal Communications Commission authorized Amazon Leo to operate roughly 7,700 satellites, and China has plans to deploy some 28,000.
The Federal Communications Commission now enforces a five-year deorbit window, tighter than the historical industry practice of deorbiting within 25 years of mission termination. Jose Pedro Ferreira of USC calls the older practice a gentleman’s agreement.
Daniel Murphy says that if 50,000 satellites orbit with a five-year design lifetime, a satellite would reenter and burn up in the atmosphere on average more than once an hour. Megaconstellation operators may deorbit satellites at the first sign of malfunction, using shorter timelines than the five-year window.
Researchers say it is too soon to know whether the metals are a serious environmental problem, but megaconstellations are growing faster than knowledge gaps can be closed. “Researchers say it’s too soon to know for sure if the metals are a serious environmental problem,” researchers said.
Martin Ross of the Aerospace Corporation calls uncertainty over potential regulator action an enterprise risk for the space industry because delayed mitigation could be larger later.
Aluminum, which makes up most spacecraft, may form aluminum oxides during ablation, the burning away of material during reentry, potentially starting chemical reactions that eat away at ozone. A 2024 Geophysical Research Letters study by USC researchers reported that a 550-pound satellite could deposit some 66 pounds of aluminum oxide nanoparticles in the upper atmosphere.
Those nanoparticles could remain aloft for upwards of 30 years and potentially catalyze ozone-destroying reactions as they settle through the stratosphere for decades after reentry. State-of-the-art ablation models disagree on the products formed, with a University of Leeds model suggesting aluminum hydroxide, not aluminum oxide, may be the main byproduct. On September 8, 2024, scientists flew from Easter Island on a modified Dassault Falcon 900 jet and observed the first Cluster II satellite reenter over the southern Pacific Ocean, capturing about 20 seconds of data.

ESA’s Draco mission will launch in 2027 with a satellite designed to fall apart, carrying an indestructible capsule to protect data collected from the satellite surface during atmospheric breakup. Researchers need more reentry measurements to test ablation models, but airborne observation is difficult and dangerous because most reentering objects fly uncontrolled and predictable destructive reentries are rare.
Vijay Thakur of Eutelsat said at an October 2025 Paris panel that he does not know what to do because no guidelines exist yet for atmospheric impacts. Chris Young of the U.K. Space Agency said at the same panel that design for demise must take priority because there is no compromise on human safety.
For decades, industry has designed spacecraft to burn up as much as possible in the atmosphere to reduce risk to lives and infrastructure, a principle called design for demise. Satellite operators are typically held responsible by national regulators for damage their spacecraft cause on the ground.
José Pedro Ferreira of USC says reentry is the only sustainable short-term way to clean up the orbital environment, or humanity may undermine its capability of accessing orbit. Stijn Lemmens of ESA says spacecraft reentry is ubiquitous but little understood and little cared about until recently.
Some atmospheric models suggest spacecraft metals in stratospheric particles could seed polar stratospheric clouds, accelerating ozone depletion. Aluminum compounds could block solar radiation and cool the planet, but might also entrap reflected ocean radiation and increase surface temperatures.
Rising reentries, from a few hundred to many thousands per year, may mean an uncontrolled geoengineering experiment on a grand scale has already begun. The U.S. Space Force’s public catalog counted some 13,700 trackable objects in low Earth orbit six years ago, and the number had climbed to nearly 25,000 by last year. The Montreal Protocol, signed in 1987, controls ozone-depleting substances and is widely considered one of the most successful environmental treaties; the ozone hole has been shrinking.
LignoSat, a wooden satellite, launched in 2024 in a Kyoto University and Sumitomo Forestry partnership. It’s a cube of magnolia wood panels to test how wood fares in space and burns up.





Join the discussion